From d8172c36317125f2a18a43097b0e975af2ed6a19 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: dotCooCoo Date: Sat, 24 Oct 2026 11:44:38 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 1/5] docs: mark tool flyout press-and-hold, Direct Selection nudge and two brush rows as built Five rows in ui-parity.md and brush-parity.md said "missing" for behavior that main has, with tests. Press-and-hold or click-drag opens a tool flyout (#2324), Direct Selection arrows nudge the selected anchors (#4486), an image file imports as a brush tip (TOOL-213-12) and each dynamic has its own pressure curve (TOOL-213-11). The Smart Guides distance and spacing row is partial: holding Cmd with the Move tool labels the distances (#4946), and spacing labels are not there. Both docs get their status line and a revision row. No percentage or estimate changed. --- docs/brush-parity.md | 7 ++++--- docs/ui-parity.md | 9 +++++---- 2 files changed, 9 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/brush-parity.md b/docs/brush-parity.md index 16eeb07198..0649115337 100644 --- a/docs/brush-parity.md +++ b/docs/brush-parity.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Brush and painting parity -> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-16 · **Change:** minor (named, stateful Brush Settings locks and visible keyboard focus; independent Brush Pose tilt-axis overrides; Transfer Wetness/Mix tool applicability; dragged preset tip preview; Hue Jitter amount track; Brush Settings minimum fields follow their Control; checkbox-only rows and non-destructive Smoothing switch; shaped-tip cursor follows the view; Color Replacement is a live toolbar tool; no brush-feel estimate changed; 2026-10-11: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, TOOL-213-7) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 +> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-24 · **Change:** minor (stale rows corrected: image brush tips and per-control pressure curves are done; named, stateful Brush Settings locks and visible keyboard focus; independent Brush Pose tilt-axis overrides; Transfer Wetness/Mix tool applicability; dragged preset tip preview; Hue Jitter amount track; Brush Settings minimum fields follow their Control; checkbox-only rows and non-destructive Smoothing switch; shaped-tip cursor follows the view; Color Replacement is a live toolbar tool; no brush-feel estimate changed; 2026-10-11: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, TOOL-213-7) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 Painting is where Photoshop users notice differences first, so it gets its own checklist: the brush engine (`crates/paint/src/brush.rs`), the Brush Settings UI @@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ tablets against Photoshop side by side. | Smoothing: amount, Pulled String, Stroke Catch-up, Catch-up on End, Adjust for Zoom | done | `brush.rs:428-438` | | Section locks | done | #174; `brush_panel_tests.rs` verifies section-specific accessible names and locked state for all 12 controls in 14 themes, plus visible themed focus, Tab blur, Space activation, minimal command patches and replay without selecting or enabling a section. | | Noise, Wet Edges, Build-up, Smoothing and Protect Texture: checkbox-only rows keep the selected controls open | done | `brush_panel_tests.rs`, #4283; Smoothing enable/disable preserves its amount and options, including imported ABR tool settings | -| Brush tip from an image file | missing | TOOL-213-12 | +| Brush tip from an image file | done | TOOL-213-12: `brush.presets.importImage` (`engine/src/preset_import_cmds.rs`, `imports_an_image_as_a_brush_tip`); Import Brushes… takes an image (`preset_files_ui.rs`, #3279) | | Erodible, Airbrush and Bristle tips (Photoshop's special tips) | partial | not audited in detail; "3D-based brushes don't work" (#1660) | | Anti-aliasing off for brushes | missing | #1666 (Pencil is the aliased path) | @@ -44,7 +44,7 @@ tablets against Photoshop side by side. |---|---|---| | Pressure drives size/opacity/flow per sample (no shared pressure within a frame) | done | #2112 | | Global pressure curve in Preferences | done | #2195 | -| Per-control pressure curves | missing | TOOL-213-11 | +| Per-control pressure curves | done | TOOL-213-11: each dynamic's own curve (`paint/src/brush.rs` `Dynamic::curve`, `paint/src/dynamics.rs` `dynamic_value`), behind each Control row's curve button (`brush_sections.rs`, `brush_panel_tests.rs` `a_dynamic_gets_its_own_response_curve`, #3294) | | Quick taps keep their pressure | partial | #1967 fixed one case; tap paints a full blob (#1798), tap sensitivity (#1933) | | Smooth pressure on Windows | partial | "jumpy" (#2046) | | Tilt and rotation drive angle/roundness | partial | macOS, X11, web; not Windows; rotation not applied (#1301) | @@ -118,6 +118,7 @@ tablets against Photoshop side by side. | Date | Change | Summary | |---|---|---| +| 2026-10-24 | minor | Stale rows corrected against main: Brush tip from an image file (TOOL-213-12, #3279) and per-control pressure curves (TOOL-213-11, #3294) are done; no brush-feel estimate changed | | 2026-10-14 | minor | Brush Pose tilt overrides are independent end to end (#3825 partial); ABR flags, legacy JSON/commands, presets and three pixel depths covered; no readiness percentage or estimate changed | | 2026-10-13 | minor | Stale "missing tool" row corrected against main: Color Replacement (`paint.colorReplacement`) is a live toolbar tool; no brush-feel estimate changed | | 2026-10-11 | minor | Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live (#3754); live retouch row now partial (Mixer Brush left) | diff --git a/docs/ui-parity.md b/docs/ui-parity.md index 8a189ad491..6ea310c35b 100644 --- a/docs/ui-parity.md +++ b/docs/ui-parity.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # UI parity: tools, handles, modifiers and feel -> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-23 · **Change:** minor (⌥ + an adjustment's shortcut reopens it at its last settings, ⌥⌘L / ⌥⌘M, #8900; Crop default mode: moving the image under the box snaps the frame's edges and centre, #8580; View › Extras hides the Move transform controls, #6699; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; Color panel modes from its panel menu, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; a picked colour recolours the selected type and shapes; Hand tool ⌘ / ⌥ are Zoom In / Zoom Out while held, #6434; the wheel steps value fields, #5473; a dragged guide shows its X or Y beside the pointer, #7680; Type options bar "T" icon scrubs the font size, #6437; Move tool: dragged selected pixels take their own outline as the selection, #7538; artboard backgrounds remain below child Free Transform previews; ⌫/Delete removes the selected smart filter, #4751; Object Finder foreground/background discrimination (#6548); rounded triangle, polygon and star corners; shape Fill/Stroke popovers accept hex RGB values, #6176; a guide let go over either ruler is removed, #6286; Crop rows corrected: saved crop presets and Delete Cropped Pixels off are done, #6562; marching ants in device pixels, #7489; Animated Zoom: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210; shape Density and Feather, TOOL-214-12, #5846; Pen Auto Add/Delete on the path being drawn, #6140; Show Transform Controls frames every selected layer; guide keys and clicks; menu bar from the keyboard, #4988; Crop tool Content-Aware Fill; on-canvas corner radius widgets, TOOL-214-12; Curvature Pen edits the active path; Clip Thumbnails to Layer Bounds; Pen ⇧ 45°; last selected tool restored at launch; Layers panel filter-type dropdown with Kind, Name and Mode, #5048; Free Transform box and marching ants follow the selection, #5297; History: the trash deletes the selected snapshot, rows drag onto the trash, #5324; smart filter reordering by drag; smart object perspective row corrected to done, #426; Free Transform H/V skew fields; toolbar tool shortcuts can be reassigned; ⇧-dragged guides land on ruler ticks; layer and selection keys; tool keys; spring-loaded tool letters; type formatting keys; Pen Auto Add/Delete, #4144; smart filter rows; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and the Add/Delete Anchor Point pair are live toolbar tools, Frame landed; no percentage changed; selection-modifier and ⌥-wheel rows match their tests) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 +> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-24 · **Change:** minor (stale rows corrected: tool flyouts open on press-and-hold or click-drag, Direct Selection arrow nudge, Smart Guides distances partial, #4946; ⌥ + an adjustment's shortcut reopens it at its last settings, ⌥⌘L / ⌥⌘M, #8900; Crop default mode: moving the image under the box snaps the frame's edges and centre, #8580; View › Extras hides the Move transform controls, #6699; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; Color panel modes from its panel menu, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; a picked colour recolours the selected type and shapes; Hand tool ⌘ / ⌥ are Zoom In / Zoom Out while held, #6434; the wheel steps value fields, #5473; a dragged guide shows its X or Y beside the pointer, #7680; Type options bar "T" icon scrubs the font size, #6437; Move tool: dragged selected pixels take their own outline as the selection, #7538; artboard backgrounds remain below child Free Transform previews; ⌫/Delete removes the selected smart filter, #4751; Object Finder foreground/background discrimination (#6548); rounded triangle, polygon and star corners; shape Fill/Stroke popovers accept hex RGB values, #6176; a guide let go over either ruler is removed, #6286; Crop rows corrected: saved crop presets and Delete Cropped Pixels off are done, #6562; marching ants in device pixels, #7489; Animated Zoom: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210; shape Density and Feather, TOOL-214-12, #5846; Pen Auto Add/Delete on the path being drawn, #6140; Show Transform Controls frames every selected layer; guide keys and clicks; menu bar from the keyboard, #4988; Crop tool Content-Aware Fill; on-canvas corner radius widgets, TOOL-214-12; Curvature Pen edits the active path; Clip Thumbnails to Layer Bounds; Pen ⇧ 45°; last selected tool restored at launch; Layers panel filter-type dropdown with Kind, Name and Mode, #5048; Free Transform box and marching ants follow the selection, #5297; History: the trash deletes the selected snapshot, rows drag onto the trash, #5324; smart filter reordering by drag; smart object perspective row corrected to done, #426; Free Transform H/V skew fields; toolbar tool shortcuts can be reassigned; ⇧-dragged guides land on ruler ticks; layer and selection keys; tool keys; spring-loaded tool letters; type formatting keys; Pen Auto Add/Delete, #4144; smart filter rows; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and the Add/Delete Anchor Point pair are live toolbar tools, Frame landed; no percentage changed; selection-modifier and ⌥-wheel rows match their tests) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 How PhotoCraft's direct manipulation compares with Photoshop 2026 (27.11.0): the toolbox, the handles and modifier keys of each gesture, nudging, snapping, numeric precision, navigation, @@ -51,7 +51,7 @@ Triangle and Curvature Pen (minus legacy Rounded Rectangle and Targeted Adjustme |---|---|---| | Letter shortcuts, ⇧+letter cycles the group, "Use Shift Key for Tool Switch" (on by default, as in Photoshop) | done | `shortcuts.rs:413` | | Group remembers the last tool used | partial | L always resets to Lasso (#2608) | -| Press-and-hold or click-drag opens the flyout | missing | right-click only (#2301) | +| Press-and-hold or click-drag opens the flyout | done | `panels.rs`: a press held 0.35 s or dragged off the button opens it, and releasing over a row picks that tool (`tool_flyout_drag_open`; tests `flyout_drag_only_opens_after_a_primary_press_leaves_its_button`, `flyout_press_drag_release_selects_the_row_without_long_press`, `long_press_type_button_selects_type_then_vertical_from_the_flyout`; #2324, #2301) | | Edit Toolbar customization | done | `edit.toolbar` | | Last selected tool restored after quitting and relaunching; temporary tool switches excluded | done | `tool_memory.rs`; `prefs_ui::tests::selected_tool_survives_a_restart_without_option_changes`, `selected_tool_excludes_temporary_switches` | @@ -91,7 +91,7 @@ Triangle and Curvature Pen (minus legacy Rounded Rectangle and Targeted Adjustme | Arrow 1 px, ⇧-arrow 10 px for layers | done | `move_mods.rs` | | Arrow nudge of a selection outline (selection tools) | done | #1502 | | Arrow nudge of the crop box, X swaps orientation | done | TOOL-214-19 | -| Arrow nudge of path points with Direct Selection | missing | no arrow handling in `direct_select.rs` | +| Arrow nudge of path points with Direct Selection | done | `direct_select.rs` `arrow_keys`: the selected anchors move 1 px, ⇧ 10 px, one History step per press (`direct_select_tests.rs` `arrow_keys_nudge_the_selected_anchors`, #4486) | | ⌘-arrow nudges the layer from any tool | missing | #2474 | | ⌥-drag duplicates, ⇧ constrains to 45° | done | `move_mods.rs` | | Dragging selected pixels shrinks the selection to them (the selection limited to where the layer has pixels, so moving again leaves no edge behind) as the drag starts, also with ⌥; the move box, snapping and Show Transform Controls use the moved pixels' bounds | done | #7538, `canvas.rs` `floating_outline` and `transform_controls_rect`, `snap_ui.rs` `follow_cut`, engine `float_cmds.rs` `CutParts::outline` | @@ -161,7 +161,7 @@ Triangle and Curvature Pen (minus legacy Rounded Rectangle and Targeted Adjustme | Snap to guides, grid, layers, document bounds and centre, selection, slices; Ctrl disables other gestures, while Distort corners snap to guides and intersections | done | `engine/src/snap.rs`, `snap_ui.rs` (actual-corner grab-offset regressions, #3632) | | Snap vector tools and transforms to the pixel grid | done | `snap_ui.rs:196` | | Smart guides (magenta alignment lines) | done | | -| Smart guide distance and spacing labels | missing | | +| Smart guide distance and spacing labels | partial | distances: with the Move tool, holding ⌘ over another layer or the canvas labels the distances in the ruler unit, and an ⌥-drag shows the distance to the copy (`move_distance.rs`, #4946); spacing labels not found | | Ruler units px/in/cm/mm/pt/pica/% | done | | | ⇧-drag a guide out of a ruler: it lands on the nearest ruler tick | done | `rulers.rs` `snap_to_tick` (#3770) | | A dragged guide shows its position beside the pointer (X for vertical, Y for horizontal, in the ruler unit) | done | `rulers.rs` `guide_drag_readout` (#7680) | @@ -244,6 +244,7 @@ Paragraph; the rest open as in-app floating windows. | Date | Change | Summary | |---|---|---| +| 2026-10-24 | minor | Stale rows corrected against main: press-and-hold or click-drag opens a tool flyout (#2324, #2301) and Direct Selection arrows nudge the selected anchors (#4486) are done; Smart Guides distances with ⌘ held are partial (#4946); no percentage changed | | 2026-10-22 | minor | Crop default mode: a drag inside an upright box snaps the frame's edges and centre to the document, layers, guides and grid, as a Classic Mode frame's move does (#8580); no percentage changed | | 2026-10-21 | minor | Adjustment clipping moved above Properties editors to remain visible in compact docks (#5231); scope, undo/redo and 8/16/32-bit pixel regressions; readiness estimate unchanged | | 2026-10-19 | minor | A guide being moved or dragged out of a ruler shows an `X:` / `Y:` position readout beside the pointer, from the zero point in the ruler unit (#7680) | From 1a7808a8dc29c0266b7f27612717130020c1f5a6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: dotCooCoo Date: Sat, 24 Oct 2026 13:20:10 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 2/5] docs: close the gap entries for the rows marked built G4 no longer lists an image file as a brush tip (TOOL-213-12) or per-control pressure curves (TOOL-213-11), and G5 no longer lists toolbar press-and-hold flyouts (#2301) or path-point nudge (#4486). Each entry gets a dated progress line, and the status line and revision history name the change. --- docs/gaps.md | 17 +++++++++++------ 1 file changed, 11 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/gaps.md b/docs/gaps.md index d878a675f5..7174595c9a 100644 --- a/docs/gaps.md +++ b/docs/gaps.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Where PhotoCraft falls short of Photoshop -> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-22 · **Change:** minor (G11: a recorded Save As imports with its format and file (`file.saveAs`, `file.saveACopy` for As a Copy) instead of as a plain Save that wrote over the played file, #7102; folder destinations stop playback until #5430; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; G9: Color panel modes, ramp and copy commands, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; G17: Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch, DIST-220-1 partial, #5485; G10: `.asl` style libraries landed, #1051; G8: area type (TYPE-218-10); G1: smart objects keep Photoshop's Cylinder warp, #4112; G8: paragraph direction buttons in the Paragraph panel and options bar, TYPE-218-2 partial; G1: 32-bit Hue/Saturation and Colorize as Photoshop does them, Photoshop-oracle floor 190/258, #5781; G11: compound layer properties export as separate Photoshop Set events, rename last, #8304; G11: Batch and droplets take the result at the action's Save step, so actions ending in Save As and Close work; G11: `.atn` steps that switch to another open document import, play and save back, #7103; G14: the Nikon D4 white level follows the sample depth, so 12-bit D4 NEFs no longer open 2.6 stops dark, #5978; G14: a Nikon NEF's Adobe RGB preview is read as Adobe RGB (maker-note ColorSpace 0x001E), #5987; Apply Layer Comp action mapping, #7101; G10: JPEG Options dialog landed, FILE-215-19 partial (no Matte, progressive Scans or size preview); G10: Cineon write; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon and Amiga IFF read; Classical Object Finder improvement; learned segmentation remains open; G4: named, stateful section locks and visible keyboard focus in Brush Settings; G4: independent Brush Pose tilt-axis overrides, #3825 partial; G4: Transfer Mixer-only controls, #3825 partial; G9: Preferences › File Handling › Save in Background takes effect, #6207, 24 of 169 preferences do nothing; G7: Content-Aware Move previews every selection the command takes, coarse then exact, TOOL-213-4 done, #6680; G4: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, TOOL-213-7; G9: Animated Zoom pref read: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210, prefs that do nothing 25 of 166; G2: a cancelled 24 MP Gaussian Blur job stops in at most 44 ms, P25 under its 200 ms budget in local runs, baseline not re-run, #6205; G1: generated large-file fixtures, a 4.38 GB PSB opens on Windows through io, FILE-216-2 done, #5107; G9: fill and adjustment layers copy and paste whole, #2344; G1: smart filter masks show on PSD open, Photoshop-oracle floor 188/258; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon read; G1: CMYK Hue/Saturation and Color Balance keep the black ink; G1: CMYK Posterize on the stored values, psd-tools oracle floor 242/309; G1: CMYK adjustment layers composite on the document's inks, Photoshop-oracle floor 165/258; G1: CMYK Brightness/Contrast on the inks, CMYK Threshold's luma; G1: modern Brightness/Contrast's brightness curve matches Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 151/258; G1: Lab documents composite on their stored L, a, b, Photoshop-oracle floor 152/258; G1: Levels on whole levels at every step, Photoshop-oracle floor 146/258, psd-tools 238/309; G1: 32-bit Brightness/Contrast legacy, Channel Mixer, Photo Filter and Black & White tint unclipped as in Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 149/258; G1: mask feathers blur with their exact variance, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: Threshold splits on Photoshop's luminosity, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: pass-through clipping base with an adjustment renders isolated, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: 16-bit Posterize as Photoshop bins it, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: Gradient Map driven by the W3C luminosity, Photoshop-oracle floor 147/258; G7: Field Blur's on-canvas pins, #3373; G4: Hue Jitter amount track, #3825 partial; G4: minimum field interaction, #3825 partial; G1: CMYK Invert, Posterize and Threshold on the inks, 16-bit Lab Invert; Photoshop-oracle floor 145/258; G11: `.atn` import maps 112 events: Select and Mask, Filter Gallery Spatter, Ripple, Crystallize, Pattern Fill layers, mask targeting, Step Backward, nudges in points, Bitmap mode; G5: Free Transform H/V skew fields; G9: toolbar tool shortcut editing; refreshed against main: G2, G5, G7, G9, G10, G13, G14, G17 items that landed; G10: DPX read and write, #1049; G4: checkbox-only Brush Settings rows; G11: Load/Save Actions `.atn` landed, AUTO-219-2 partial; G5: hold-a-key spring-loaded tools landed, #2672; G1: #2465 fixed; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and Add/Delete Anchor Point are live tools, so only Art History Brush is missing; no estimate changed) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 +> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-24 · **Change:** minor (stale entries corrected: G4 image brush tips and per-control pressure curves are done, TOOL-213-12, TOOL-213-11; G5 tool flyouts open on press-and-hold or click-drag, #2301, and Direct Selection arrows nudge path points, #4486; G11: a recorded Save As imports with its format and file (`file.saveAs`, `file.saveACopy` for As a Copy) instead of as a plain Save that wrote over the played file, #7102; folder destinations stop playback until #5430; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; G9: Color panel modes, ramp and copy commands, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; G17: Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch, DIST-220-1 partial, #5485; G10: `.asl` style libraries landed, #1051; G8: area type (TYPE-218-10); G1: smart objects keep Photoshop's Cylinder warp, #4112; G8: paragraph direction buttons in the Paragraph panel and options bar, TYPE-218-2 partial; G1: 32-bit Hue/Saturation and Colorize as Photoshop does them, Photoshop-oracle floor 190/258, #5781; G11: compound layer properties export as separate Photoshop Set events, rename last, #8304; G11: Batch and droplets take the result at the action's Save step, so actions ending in Save As and Close work; G11: `.atn` steps that switch to another open document import, play and save back, #7103; G14: the Nikon D4 white level follows the sample depth, so 12-bit D4 NEFs no longer open 2.6 stops dark, #5978; G14: a Nikon NEF's Adobe RGB preview is read as Adobe RGB (maker-note ColorSpace 0x001E), #5987; Apply Layer Comp action mapping, #7101; G10: JPEG Options dialog landed, FILE-215-19 partial (no Matte, progressive Scans or size preview); G10: Cineon write; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon and Amiga IFF read; Classical Object Finder improvement; learned segmentation remains open; G4: named, stateful section locks and visible keyboard focus in Brush Settings; G4: independent Brush Pose tilt-axis overrides, #3825 partial; G4: Transfer Mixer-only controls, #3825 partial; G9: Preferences › File Handling › Save in Background takes effect, #6207, 24 of 169 preferences do nothing; G7: Content-Aware Move previews every selection the command takes, coarse then exact, TOOL-213-4 done, #6680; G4: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, TOOL-213-7; G9: Animated Zoom pref read: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210, prefs that do nothing 25 of 166; G2: a cancelled 24 MP Gaussian Blur job stops in at most 44 ms, P25 under its 200 ms budget in local runs, baseline not re-run, #6205; G1: generated large-file fixtures, a 4.38 GB PSB opens on Windows through io, FILE-216-2 done, #5107; G9: fill and adjustment layers copy and paste whole, #2344; G1: smart filter masks show on PSD open, Photoshop-oracle floor 188/258; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon read; G1: CMYK Hue/Saturation and Color Balance keep the black ink; G1: CMYK Posterize on the stored values, psd-tools oracle floor 242/309; G1: CMYK adjustment layers composite on the document's inks, Photoshop-oracle floor 165/258; G1: CMYK Brightness/Contrast on the inks, CMYK Threshold's luma; G1: modern Brightness/Contrast's brightness curve matches Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 151/258; G1: Lab documents composite on their stored L, a, b, Photoshop-oracle floor 152/258; G1: Levels on whole levels at every step, Photoshop-oracle floor 146/258, psd-tools 238/309; G1: 32-bit Brightness/Contrast legacy, Channel Mixer, Photo Filter and Black & White tint unclipped as in Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 149/258; G1: mask feathers blur with their exact variance, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: Threshold splits on Photoshop's luminosity, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: pass-through clipping base with an adjustment renders isolated, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: 16-bit Posterize as Photoshop bins it, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: Gradient Map driven by the W3C luminosity, Photoshop-oracle floor 147/258; G7: Field Blur's on-canvas pins, #3373; G4: Hue Jitter amount track, #3825 partial; G4: minimum field interaction, #3825 partial; G1: CMYK Invert, Posterize and Threshold on the inks, 16-bit Lab Invert; Photoshop-oracle floor 145/258; G11: `.atn` import maps 112 events: Select and Mask, Filter Gallery Spatter, Ripple, Crystallize, Pattern Fill layers, mask targeting, Step Backward, nudges in points, Bitmap mode; G5: Free Transform H/V skew fields; G9: toolbar tool shortcut editing; refreshed against main: G2, G5, G7, G9, G10, G13, G14, G17 items that landed; G10: DPX read and write, #1049; G4: checkbox-only Brush Settings rows; G11: Load/Save Actions `.atn` landed, AUTO-219-2 partial; G5: hold-a-key spring-loaded tools landed, #2672; G1: #2465 fixed; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and Add/Delete Anchor Point are live tools, so only Art History Brush is missing; no estimate changed) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 Every known shortfall against Photoshop 2026 (27.11.0), one entry each, ranked by user impact on the way to beta. This is the work list agents pick from: take the highest-ranked entry that @@ -208,6 +208,9 @@ what an agent can't finish alone. - **Estimate:** 250–400 h (many overlap with other gaps; count each fix once). ### G4. Brush feel +- **Progress (2026-10-24, stale entries corrected):** an image file can be imported as a brush + tip (TOOL-213-12, #3279), and each brush dynamic has its own pressure curve (TOOL-213-11, + #3294). The other brush-feel gaps remain open. - **Progress (2026-10-13, #3825 partial):** Transfer’s Wetness Jitter and Mix Jitter blocks are disabled outside the Mixer Brush, retaining their saved settings. Opacity and Flow keep their existing availability; other layout and brush-feel gaps remain open. @@ -235,16 +238,17 @@ what an agent can't finish alone. interpolation and smoothing problems (#2138), edge falloff (#2149), pixelated cursor vs Photoshop (#1433), brush rotation not driven by pen rotation (#1301); no live preview for the Mixer Brush yet (TOOL-213-7, in PR #3627; the other brush tools draw live, Spot Healing and Remove - compute on release as in Photoshop); no image file as a brush tip (TOOL-213-12); per-control pressure - curves (TOOL-213-11); 4 of Photoshop's symmetry modes. + compute on release as in Photoshop); 4 of Photoshop's symmetry modes. - **Detail:** [`brush-parity.md`](brush-parity.md). - **Estimate:** 100–180 h. **Human:** checking feel on real tablets. ### G5. Transform, handles and modifiers +- **Progress (2026-10-24, stale entries corrected):** a toolbar button held or dragged off opens + its tool flyout (#2324, #2301), and Direct Selection's arrow keys nudge the selected path + points (#4486). The other transform and modifier gaps remain open. - **Missing:** the full interpolation list; blend mode/opacity edits during - a transform (#1384); path-point nudge; autoscroll at the edge while selecting (#2231); - wheel and pinch behaviour (#2485, #2463, #1989); - toolbar press-and-hold flyouts (#2301). + a transform (#1384); autoscroll at the edge while selecting (#2231); + wheel and pinch behaviour (#2485, #2463, #1989). - **Done since the re-measure (2026-10-10 to 12):** right-click menu during Free Transform (TOOL-214-5); commit/cancel buttons in the options bar (#2442); transform keeps the layer's place in the stack (#2439, #2480); Hand tool no longer interrupts a transform (#2302, #2327); @@ -358,6 +362,7 @@ what an agent can't finish alone. | Date | Change | Summary | |---|---|---| +| 2026-10-24 | minor | Stale entries corrected against main: G4 image brush tips (TOOL-213-12, #3279) and per-control pressure curves (TOOL-213-11, #3294) are done; G5 tool flyouts on press-and-hold or click-drag (#2324, #2301) and Direct Selection path-point nudge (#4486) are done; estimates unchanged | | 2026-10-22 | minor | G17: Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch (#5485), DIST-220-1 partial; estimate unchanged | | 2026-10-22 | minor | G1: 32-bit Hue/Saturation unclipped with Photoshop's saturation factor, bright colours keep their hue, Colorize's saturation scaled by 1 − \|Lightness\|; photoshop rgb32 hue-saturation and hue-saturation-colorize pass; Photoshop-oracle floor 188 → 190 of 258 (#5781) | | 2026-10-21 | minor | G9: adjustment clipping remains visible in compact Properties (#5231); no readiness percentage or estimate changed | From c2819f479b4bf3196cf41be28e25a2f0f63c1218 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: dotCooCoo Date: Sat, 24 Oct 2026 14:15:40 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 3/5] docs: cite #2324 for the G5 flyout entry, as #2301 is still open --- docs/gaps.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/gaps.md b/docs/gaps.md index 7174595c9a..94d16b3486 100644 --- a/docs/gaps.md +++ b/docs/gaps.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Where PhotoCraft falls short of Photoshop -> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-24 · **Change:** minor (stale entries corrected: G4 image brush tips and per-control pressure curves are done, TOOL-213-12, TOOL-213-11; G5 tool flyouts open on press-and-hold or click-drag, #2301, and Direct Selection arrows nudge path points, #4486; G11: a recorded Save As imports with its format and file (`file.saveAs`, `file.saveACopy` for As a Copy) instead of as a plain Save that wrote over the played file, #7102; folder destinations stop playback until #5430; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; G9: Color panel modes, ramp and copy commands, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; G17: Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch, DIST-220-1 partial, #5485; G10: `.asl` style libraries landed, #1051; G8: area type (TYPE-218-10); G1: smart objects keep Photoshop's Cylinder warp, #4112; G8: paragraph direction buttons in the Paragraph panel and options bar, TYPE-218-2 partial; G1: 32-bit Hue/Saturation and Colorize as Photoshop does them, Photoshop-oracle floor 190/258, #5781; G11: compound layer properties export as separate Photoshop Set events, rename last, #8304; G11: Batch and droplets take the result at the action's Save step, so actions ending in Save As and Close work; G11: `.atn` steps that switch to another open document import, play and save back, #7103; G14: the Nikon D4 white level follows the sample depth, so 12-bit D4 NEFs no longer open 2.6 stops dark, #5978; G14: a Nikon NEF's Adobe RGB preview is read as Adobe RGB (maker-note ColorSpace 0x001E), #5987; Apply Layer Comp action mapping, #7101; G10: JPEG Options dialog landed, FILE-215-19 partial (no Matte, progressive Scans or size preview); G10: Cineon write; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon and Amiga IFF read; Classical Object Finder improvement; learned segmentation remains open; G4: named, stateful section locks and visible keyboard focus in Brush Settings; G4: independent Brush Pose tilt-axis overrides, #3825 partial; G4: Transfer Mixer-only controls, #3825 partial; G9: Preferences › File Handling › Save in Background takes effect, #6207, 24 of 169 preferences do nothing; G7: Content-Aware Move previews every selection the command takes, coarse then exact, TOOL-213-4 done, #6680; G4: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, TOOL-213-7; G9: Animated Zoom pref read: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210, prefs that do nothing 25 of 166; G2: a cancelled 24 MP Gaussian Blur job stops in at most 44 ms, P25 under its 200 ms budget in local runs, baseline not re-run, #6205; G1: generated large-file fixtures, a 4.38 GB PSB opens on Windows through io, FILE-216-2 done, #5107; G9: fill and adjustment layers copy and paste whole, #2344; G1: smart filter masks show on PSD open, Photoshop-oracle floor 188/258; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon read; G1: CMYK Hue/Saturation and Color Balance keep the black ink; G1: CMYK Posterize on the stored values, psd-tools oracle floor 242/309; G1: CMYK adjustment layers composite on the document's inks, Photoshop-oracle floor 165/258; G1: CMYK Brightness/Contrast on the inks, CMYK Threshold's luma; G1: modern Brightness/Contrast's brightness curve matches Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 151/258; G1: Lab documents composite on their stored L, a, b, Photoshop-oracle floor 152/258; G1: Levels on whole levels at every step, Photoshop-oracle floor 146/258, psd-tools 238/309; G1: 32-bit Brightness/Contrast legacy, Channel Mixer, Photo Filter and Black & White tint unclipped as in Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 149/258; G1: mask feathers blur with their exact variance, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: Threshold splits on Photoshop's luminosity, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: pass-through clipping base with an adjustment renders isolated, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: 16-bit Posterize as Photoshop bins it, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: Gradient Map driven by the W3C luminosity, Photoshop-oracle floor 147/258; G7: Field Blur's on-canvas pins, #3373; G4: Hue Jitter amount track, #3825 partial; G4: minimum field interaction, #3825 partial; G1: CMYK Invert, Posterize and Threshold on the inks, 16-bit Lab Invert; Photoshop-oracle floor 145/258; G11: `.atn` import maps 112 events: Select and Mask, Filter Gallery Spatter, Ripple, Crystallize, Pattern Fill layers, mask targeting, Step Backward, nudges in points, Bitmap mode; G5: Free Transform H/V skew fields; G9: toolbar tool shortcut editing; refreshed against main: G2, G5, G7, G9, G10, G13, G14, G17 items that landed; G10: DPX read and write, #1049; G4: checkbox-only Brush Settings rows; G11: Load/Save Actions `.atn` landed, AUTO-219-2 partial; G5: hold-a-key spring-loaded tools landed, #2672; G1: #2465 fixed; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and Add/Delete Anchor Point are live tools, so only Art History Brush is missing; no estimate changed) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 +> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-24 · **Change:** minor (stale entries corrected: G4 image brush tips and per-control pressure curves are done, TOOL-213-12, TOOL-213-11; G5 tool flyouts open on press-and-hold or click-drag, #2324, and Direct Selection arrows nudge path points, #4486; G11: a recorded Save As imports with its format and file (`file.saveAs`, `file.saveACopy` for As a Copy) instead of as a plain Save that wrote over the played file, #7102; folder destinations stop playback until #5430; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; G9: Color panel modes, ramp and copy commands, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; G17: Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch, DIST-220-1 partial, #5485; G10: `.asl` style libraries landed, #1051; G8: area type (TYPE-218-10); G1: smart objects keep Photoshop's Cylinder warp, #4112; G8: paragraph direction buttons in the Paragraph panel and options bar, TYPE-218-2 partial; G1: 32-bit Hue/Saturation and Colorize as Photoshop does them, Photoshop-oracle floor 190/258, #5781; G11: compound layer properties export as separate Photoshop Set events, rename last, #8304; G11: Batch and droplets take the result at the action's Save step, so actions ending in Save As and Close work; G11: `.atn` steps that switch to another open document import, play and save back, #7103; G14: the Nikon D4 white level follows the sample depth, so 12-bit D4 NEFs no longer open 2.6 stops dark, #5978; G14: a Nikon NEF's Adobe RGB preview is read as Adobe RGB (maker-note ColorSpace 0x001E), #5987; Apply Layer Comp action mapping, #7101; G10: JPEG Options dialog landed, FILE-215-19 partial (no Matte, progressive Scans or size preview); G10: Cineon write; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon and Amiga IFF read; Classical Object Finder improvement; learned segmentation remains open; G4: named, stateful section locks and visible keyboard focus in Brush Settings; G4: independent Brush Pose tilt-axis overrides, #3825 partial; G4: Transfer Mixer-only controls, #3825 partial; G9: Preferences › File Handling › Save in Background takes effect, #6207, 24 of 169 preferences do nothing; G7: Content-Aware Move previews every selection the command takes, coarse then exact, TOOL-213-4 done, #6680; G4: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, TOOL-213-7; G9: Animated Zoom pref read: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210, prefs that do nothing 25 of 166; G2: a cancelled 24 MP Gaussian Blur job stops in at most 44 ms, P25 under its 200 ms budget in local runs, baseline not re-run, #6205; G1: generated large-file fixtures, a 4.38 GB PSB opens on Windows through io, FILE-216-2 done, #5107; G9: fill and adjustment layers copy and paste whole, #2344; G1: smart filter masks show on PSD open, Photoshop-oracle floor 188/258; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon read; G1: CMYK Hue/Saturation and Color Balance keep the black ink; G1: CMYK Posterize on the stored values, psd-tools oracle floor 242/309; G1: CMYK adjustment layers composite on the document's inks, Photoshop-oracle floor 165/258; G1: CMYK Brightness/Contrast on the inks, CMYK Threshold's luma; G1: modern Brightness/Contrast's brightness curve matches Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 151/258; G1: Lab documents composite on their stored L, a, b, Photoshop-oracle floor 152/258; G1: Levels on whole levels at every step, Photoshop-oracle floor 146/258, psd-tools 238/309; G1: 32-bit Brightness/Contrast legacy, Channel Mixer, Photo Filter and Black & White tint unclipped as in Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 149/258; G1: mask feathers blur with their exact variance, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: Threshold splits on Photoshop's luminosity, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: pass-through clipping base with an adjustment renders isolated, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: 16-bit Posterize as Photoshop bins it, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: Gradient Map driven by the W3C luminosity, Photoshop-oracle floor 147/258; G7: Field Blur's on-canvas pins, #3373; G4: Hue Jitter amount track, #3825 partial; G4: minimum field interaction, #3825 partial; G1: CMYK Invert, Posterize and Threshold on the inks, 16-bit Lab Invert; Photoshop-oracle floor 145/258; G11: `.atn` import maps 112 events: Select and Mask, Filter Gallery Spatter, Ripple, Crystallize, Pattern Fill layers, mask targeting, Step Backward, nudges in points, Bitmap mode; G5: Free Transform H/V skew fields; G9: toolbar tool shortcut editing; refreshed against main: G2, G5, G7, G9, G10, G13, G14, G17 items that landed; G10: DPX read and write, #1049; G4: checkbox-only Brush Settings rows; G11: Load/Save Actions `.atn` landed, AUTO-219-2 partial; G5: hold-a-key spring-loaded tools landed, #2672; G1: #2465 fixed; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and Add/Delete Anchor Point are live tools, so only Art History Brush is missing; no estimate changed) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 Every known shortfall against Photoshop 2026 (27.11.0), one entry each, ranked by user impact on the way to beta. This is the work list agents pick from: take the highest-ranked entry that @@ -244,8 +244,8 @@ what an agent can't finish alone. ### G5. Transform, handles and modifiers - **Progress (2026-10-24, stale entries corrected):** a toolbar button held or dragged off opens - its tool flyout (#2324, #2301), and Direct Selection's arrow keys nudge the selected path - points (#4486). The other transform and modifier gaps remain open. + its tool flyout (#2324; issue #2301 is still open), and Direct Selection's arrow keys nudge + the selected path points (#4486). The other transform and modifier gaps remain open. - **Missing:** the full interpolation list; blend mode/opacity edits during a transform (#1384); autoscroll at the edge while selecting (#2231); wheel and pinch behaviour (#2485, #2463, #1989). @@ -362,7 +362,7 @@ what an agent can't finish alone. | Date | Change | Summary | |---|---|---| -| 2026-10-24 | minor | Stale entries corrected against main: G4 image brush tips (TOOL-213-12, #3279) and per-control pressure curves (TOOL-213-11, #3294) are done; G5 tool flyouts on press-and-hold or click-drag (#2324, #2301) and Direct Selection path-point nudge (#4486) are done; estimates unchanged | +| 2026-10-24 | minor | Stale entries corrected against main: G4 image brush tips (TOOL-213-12, #3279) and per-control pressure curves (TOOL-213-11, #3294) are done; G5 tool flyouts on press-and-hold or click-drag (#2324) and Direct Selection path-point nudge (#4486) are done; estimates unchanged | | 2026-10-22 | minor | G17: Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch (#5485), DIST-220-1 partial; estimate unchanged | | 2026-10-22 | minor | G1: 32-bit Hue/Saturation unclipped with Photoshop's saturation factor, bright colours keep their hue, Colorize's saturation scaled by 1 − \|Lightness\|; photoshop rgb32 hue-saturation and hue-saturation-colorize pass; Photoshop-oracle floor 188 → 190 of 258 (#5781) | | 2026-10-21 | minor | G9: adjustment clipping remains visible in compact Properties (#5231); no readiness percentage or estimate changed | From ab6eddcbde8fbb7f2e86b0540a89077a4c266522 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: dotCooCoo Date: Fri, 30 Oct 2026 13:32:01 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 4/5] docs: Direct Selection arrow nudge and Smart Guides distances stay partial Photoshop's arrow keys also nudge a selected path segment with Direct Selection, which PhotoCraft does not do yet, so that row is partial and G5 keeps segment nudge in its missing list. The Smart Guides row now also names the missing distances during an ordinary Move drag. --- docs/gaps.md | 12 +++++++----- docs/ui-parity.md | 8 ++++---- 2 files changed, 11 insertions(+), 9 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/gaps.md b/docs/gaps.md index 1f8ec34cd7..fde41edf45 100644 --- a/docs/gaps.md +++ b/docs/gaps.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Where PhotoCraft falls short of Photoshop -> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-27 · **Change:** minor (stale entries corrected: G4 image brush tips and per-control pressure curves are done, TOOL-213-12, TOOL-213-11; G5 tool flyouts open on press-and-hold or click-drag, #2324, and Direct Selection arrows nudge path points, #4486; Smooth and Feather command masks cropped to selection bounds plus blur reach; G1: Halftone Pattern Filter Gallery settings survive PSD/PSB saves (#8940); cropped selection morphology and command mask conversion performance evidence added; G9: 12 of 181 preferences do nothing, as the scorecard prefs audit counts them; G6: Art History Brush landed as partial, TOOL-213-20, #1610, so no toolbar tool is missing; G4: five hard-round built-in presets use 5% spacing to remove stacked-tip outlines and reduce pressure-opacity bands, #8842; G9: Crop tool canvas menu, #6561; G2: Content-Aware Scale seam carving 1.65–3.6× faster with unchanged output, P28 row 3.3 → 1.6 s on a 4-core VM, #5236; G9: UI scale presets done, 105–120% steps, #3222; G14: lossy DNG, raw sidecars, Camera Raw Defaults live, Calibration and Auto, CR3 assessed as not clean-room feasible; G8: PSD type on a path opens on its path and saves back into the file's `Txt2`, #7962; G11: a recorded Save As imports with its format and file (`file.saveAs`, `file.saveACopy` for As a Copy) instead of as a plain Save that wrote over the played file, #7102; folder destinations stop playback until #5430; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; G9: Color panel modes, ramp and copy commands, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; G17: Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch, DIST-220-1 partial, #5485; G10: `.asl` style libraries landed, #1051; G8: area type (TYPE-218-10); G1: smart objects keep Photoshop's Cylinder warp, #4112; G8: paragraph direction buttons in the Paragraph panel and options bar, TYPE-218-2 partial; G1: 32-bit Hue/Saturation and Colorize as Photoshop does them, Photoshop-oracle floor 190/258, #5781; G11: compound layer properties export as separate Photoshop Set events, rename last, #8304; G11: Batch and droplets take the result at the action's Save step, so actions ending in Save As and Close work; G11: `.atn` steps that switch to another open document import, play and save back, #7103; G14: the Nikon D4 white level follows the sample depth, so 12-bit D4 NEFs no longer open 2.6 stops dark, #5978; G14: a Nikon NEF's Adobe RGB preview is read as Adobe RGB (maker-note ColorSpace 0x001E), #5987; Apply Layer Comp action mapping, #7101; G10: JPEG Options dialog landed, FILE-215-19 partial (no Matte, progressive Scans or size preview); G10: Cineon write; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon and Amiga IFF read; Classical Object Finder improvement; learned segmentation remains open; G4: named, stateful section locks and visible keyboard focus in Brush Settings; G4: independent Brush Pose tilt-axis overrides, #3825 partial; G4: Transfer Mixer-only controls, #3825 partial; G9: Preferences › File Handling › Save in Background takes effect, #6207, 24 of 169 preferences do nothing; G7: Content-Aware Move previews every selection the command takes, coarse then exact, TOOL-213-4 done, #6680; G4: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, TOOL-213-7; G9: Animated Zoom pref read: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210, prefs that do nothing 25 of 166; G2: a cancelled 24 MP Gaussian Blur job stops in at most 44 ms, P25 under its 200 ms budget in local runs, baseline not re-run, #6205; G1: generated large-file fixtures, a 4.38 GB PSB opens on Windows through io, FILE-216-2 done, #5107; G9: fill and adjustment layers copy and paste whole, #2344; G1: smart filter masks show on PSD open, Photoshop-oracle floor 188/258; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon read; G1: CMYK Hue/Saturation and Color Balance keep the black ink; G1: CMYK Posterize on the stored values, psd-tools oracle floor 242/309; G1: CMYK adjustment layers composite on the document's inks, Photoshop-oracle floor 165/258; G1: CMYK Brightness/Contrast on the inks, CMYK Threshold's luma; G1: modern Brightness/Contrast's brightness curve matches Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 151/258; G1: Lab documents composite on their stored L, a, b, Photoshop-oracle floor 152/258; G1: Levels on whole levels at every step, Photoshop-oracle floor 146/258, psd-tools 238/309; G1: 32-bit Brightness/Contrast legacy, Channel Mixer, Photo Filter and Black & White tint unclipped as in Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 149/258; G1: mask feathers blur with their exact variance, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: Threshold splits on Photoshop's luminosity, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: pass-through clipping base with an adjustment renders isolated, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: 16-bit Posterize as Photoshop bins it, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: Gradient Map driven by the W3C luminosity, Photoshop-oracle floor 147/258; G7: Field Blur's on-canvas pins, #3373; G4: Hue Jitter amount track, #3825 partial; G4: minimum field interaction, #3825 partial; G1: CMYK Invert, Posterize and Threshold on the inks, 16-bit Lab Invert; Photoshop-oracle floor 145/258; G11: `.atn` import maps 112 events: Select and Mask, Filter Gallery Spatter, Ripple, Crystallize, Pattern Fill layers, mask targeting, Step Backward, nudges in points, Bitmap mode; G5: Free Transform H/V skew fields; G9: toolbar tool shortcut editing; refreshed against main: G2, G5, G7, G9, G10, G13, G14, G17 items that landed; G10: DPX read and write, #1049; G4: checkbox-only Brush Settings rows; G11: Load/Save Actions `.atn` landed, AUTO-219-2 partial; G5: hold-a-key spring-loaded tools landed, #2672; G1: #2465 fixed; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and Add/Delete Anchor Point are live tools, so only Art History Brush is missing; no estimate changed; G10: Amiga IFF write; G10: PSD spot channels in Photoshop's polarity, earlier PhotoCraft PSDs keep their ink, #7415 split; G10: TIFF alpha and spot channels written and read as extra samples, FILE-215-7 done, FILE-215-17's TIFF part, #7415) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 +> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-27 · **Change:** minor (stale entries corrected: G4 image brush tips and per-control pressure curves are done, TOOL-213-12, TOOL-213-11; G5 tool flyouts open on press-and-hold or click-drag, #2324, and Direct Selection arrows nudge anchor points, #4486; Smooth and Feather command masks cropped to selection bounds plus blur reach; G1: Halftone Pattern Filter Gallery settings survive PSD/PSB saves (#8940); cropped selection morphology and command mask conversion performance evidence added; G9: 12 of 181 preferences do nothing, as the scorecard prefs audit counts them; G6: Art History Brush landed as partial, TOOL-213-20, #1610, so no toolbar tool is missing; G4: five hard-round built-in presets use 5% spacing to remove stacked-tip outlines and reduce pressure-opacity bands, #8842; G9: Crop tool canvas menu, #6561; G2: Content-Aware Scale seam carving 1.65–3.6× faster with unchanged output, P28 row 3.3 → 1.6 s on a 4-core VM, #5236; G9: UI scale presets done, 105–120% steps, #3222; G14: lossy DNG, raw sidecars, Camera Raw Defaults live, Calibration and Auto, CR3 assessed as not clean-room feasible; G8: PSD type on a path opens on its path and saves back into the file's `Txt2`, #7962; G11: a recorded Save As imports with its format and file (`file.saveAs`, `file.saveACopy` for As a Copy) instead of as a plain Save that wrote over the played file, #7102; folder destinations stop playback until #5430; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; G9: Color panel modes, ramp and copy commands, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; G17: Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch, DIST-220-1 partial, #5485; G10: `.asl` style libraries landed, #1051; G8: area type (TYPE-218-10); G1: smart objects keep Photoshop's Cylinder warp, #4112; G8: paragraph direction buttons in the Paragraph panel and options bar, TYPE-218-2 partial; G1: 32-bit Hue/Saturation and Colorize as Photoshop does them, Photoshop-oracle floor 190/258, #5781; G11: compound layer properties export as separate Photoshop Set events, rename last, #8304; G11: Batch and droplets take the result at the action's Save step, so actions ending in Save As and Close work; G11: `.atn` steps that switch to another open document import, play and save back, #7103; G14: the Nikon D4 white level follows the sample depth, so 12-bit D4 NEFs no longer open 2.6 stops dark, #5978; G14: a Nikon NEF's Adobe RGB preview is read as Adobe RGB (maker-note ColorSpace 0x001E), #5987; Apply Layer Comp action mapping, #7101; G10: JPEG Options dialog landed, FILE-215-19 partial (no Matte, progressive Scans or size preview); G10: Cineon write; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon and Amiga IFF read; Classical Object Finder improvement; learned segmentation remains open; G4: named, stateful section locks and visible keyboard focus in Brush Settings; G4: independent Brush Pose tilt-axis overrides, #3825 partial; G4: Transfer Mixer-only controls, #3825 partial; G9: Preferences › File Handling › Save in Background takes effect, #6207, 24 of 169 preferences do nothing; G7: Content-Aware Move previews every selection the command takes, coarse then exact, TOOL-213-4 done, #6680; G4: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, TOOL-213-7; G9: Animated Zoom pref read: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210, prefs that do nothing 25 of 166; G2: a cancelled 24 MP Gaussian Blur job stops in at most 44 ms, P25 under its 200 ms budget in local runs, baseline not re-run, #6205; G1: generated large-file fixtures, a 4.38 GB PSB opens on Windows through io, FILE-216-2 done, #5107; G9: fill and adjustment layers copy and paste whole, #2344; G1: smart filter masks show on PSD open, Photoshop-oracle floor 188/258; G10: DPX read and write, #1049, Cineon read; G1: CMYK Hue/Saturation and Color Balance keep the black ink; G1: CMYK Posterize on the stored values, psd-tools oracle floor 242/309; G1: CMYK adjustment layers composite on the document's inks, Photoshop-oracle floor 165/258; G1: CMYK Brightness/Contrast on the inks, CMYK Threshold's luma; G1: modern Brightness/Contrast's brightness curve matches Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 151/258; G1: Lab documents composite on their stored L, a, b, Photoshop-oracle floor 152/258; G1: Levels on whole levels at every step, Photoshop-oracle floor 146/258, psd-tools 238/309; G1: 32-bit Brightness/Contrast legacy, Channel Mixer, Photo Filter and Black & White tint unclipped as in Photoshop, Photoshop-oracle floor 149/258; G1: mask feathers blur with their exact variance, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: Threshold splits on Photoshop's luminosity, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: pass-through clipping base with an adjustment renders isolated, psd-tools oracle floor 240/309; G1: 16-bit Posterize as Photoshop bins it, psd-tools oracle floor 241/309; G1: Gradient Map driven by the W3C luminosity, Photoshop-oracle floor 147/258; G7: Field Blur's on-canvas pins, #3373; G4: Hue Jitter amount track, #3825 partial; G4: minimum field interaction, #3825 partial; G1: CMYK Invert, Posterize and Threshold on the inks, 16-bit Lab Invert; Photoshop-oracle floor 145/258; G11: `.atn` import maps 112 events: Select and Mask, Filter Gallery Spatter, Ripple, Crystallize, Pattern Fill layers, mask targeting, Step Backward, nudges in points, Bitmap mode; G5: Free Transform H/V skew fields; G9: toolbar tool shortcut editing; refreshed against main: G2, G5, G7, G9, G10, G13, G14, G17 items that landed; G10: DPX read and write, #1049; G4: checkbox-only Brush Settings rows; G11: Load/Save Actions `.atn` landed, AUTO-219-2 partial; G5: hold-a-key spring-loaded tools landed, #2672; G1: #2465 fixed; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and Add/Delete Anchor Point are live tools, so only Art History Brush is missing; no estimate changed; G10: Amiga IFF write; G10: PSD spot channels in Photoshop's polarity, earlier PhotoCraft PSDs keep their ink, #7415 split; G10: TIFF alpha and spot channels written and read as extra samples, FILE-215-7 done, FILE-215-17's TIFF part, #7415) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 Every known shortfall against Photoshop 2026 (27.11.0), one entry each, ranked by user impact on the way to beta. This is the work list agents pick from: take the highest-ranked entry that @@ -263,9 +263,11 @@ what an agent can't finish alone. ### G5. Transform, handles and modifiers - **Progress (2026-10-24, stale entries corrected):** a toolbar button held or dragged off opens its tool flyout (#2324; issue #2301 is still open), and Direct Selection's arrow keys nudge - the selected path points (#4486). The other transform and modifier gaps remain open. -- **Missing:** the full interpolation list; blend mode/opacity edits during - a transform (#1384); autoscroll at the edge while selecting (#2231); + the selected anchor points (#4486; a selected segment is not nudged yet). The other transform + and modifier gaps remain open. +- **Missing:** Direct Selection arrow nudge of a selected path segment; the full + interpolation list; blend mode/opacity edits during a transform (#1384); + autoscroll at the edge while selecting (#2231); wheel and pinch behaviour (#2485, #2463, #1989). - **Done since the re-measure (2026-10-10 to 12):** right-click menu during Free Transform (TOOL-214-5); commit/cancel buttons in the options bar (#2442); transform keeps the layer's @@ -416,7 +418,7 @@ what an agent can't finish alone. | 2026-10-23 | minor | G7: Select and Mask workspace (Photoshop's layout, its tools as `select.refineEdge` edits, Real-Time Refinement, High Quality Preview), #7069, #8148; Refine Hair, Object Aware and Presets remain; no estimate changed | | 2026-10-25 | minor | G9: the count of preferences that do nothing is the scorecard's again, 12 of 178 (it still said 24 of 171, from 2026-10-15); no estimate changed | | 2026-10-25 | minor | G6: Art History Brush landed as partial (TOOL-213-20, #1610), so no toolbar tool is missing; no percentage or estimate changed | -| 2026-10-24 | minor | Stale entries corrected against main: G4 image brush tips (TOOL-213-12, #3279) and per-control pressure curves (TOOL-213-11, #3294) are done; G5 tool flyouts on press-and-hold or click-drag (#2324) and Direct Selection path-point nudge (#4486) are done; estimates unchanged | +| 2026-10-24 | minor | Stale entries corrected against main: G4 image brush tips (TOOL-213-12, #3279) and per-control pressure curves (TOOL-213-11, #3294) are done; G5 tool flyouts on press-and-hold or click-drag (#2324) are done, and Direct Selection nudge of anchors (#4486) is done while segment nudge stays listed; estimates unchanged | | 2026-10-23 | minor | G4: hard-round built-in presets use 5% spacing (#8842), guarded by large-stroke outline and pressure-opacity pixel regressions at 8/16/32-bit; percentages and estimates unchanged | | 2026-10-23 | minor | G10: PSD stores and reads spot channels as Photoshop does (ink 0 = solid) with their identifiers (1053); PSDs from PhotoCraft 0.1.0–0.16.0 keep their ink (#7415 split, part 4); FILE-215-17 stays partial; estimate unchanged | | 2026-10-23 | minor | G10: TIFF alpha and spot channels written and read as extra samples with Photoshop's channel resources, PSD output unchanged (#7415); FILE-215-7 leaves the list, FILE-215-17 narrows to RGB/CMYK spot preview and PDF Separation | diff --git a/docs/ui-parity.md b/docs/ui-parity.md index f4fa613650..9106ba104a 100644 --- a/docs/ui-parity.md +++ b/docs/ui-parity.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # UI parity: tools, handles, modifiers and feel -> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-29 · **Change:** minor (stale rows corrected: tool flyouts open on press-and-hold or click-drag, Direct Selection arrow nudge, Smart Guides distances partial, #4946; Free Transform of several selected layers, #6501; Path Operations fixes: the first component keeps combining, a hidden component selection is left alone, a dragged live shape stays live, a refused Pen draft ends once; Pen, Freeform Pen, Curvature Pen and Path Selection Path Operations menu, which changes selected components, `+` / `-` keys, #1397; the Pen carries on an open shape or vector mask path; selection-aware font controls, pending caret fonts and focused commit, plus direct font-name editing with a compact no-match message, #9338; New Group dialog and button modifiers; new layers go into an open active group and join a clipping mask, except that type, shapes, pastes and placed files go above a group whose lock would refuse them; Color panel Hue and Brightness Cube show the out-of-gamut ⚠ and nearest printable colour when the field is at least 53 pt tall, #8672; 12 of 181 preferences do nothing, from the scorecard; Art History Brush in the History group of the Y flyout, partial, TOOL-213-20, #1610; Histogram panel: Compact / Expanded / All Channels views, Luminosity and Colors channels, Source, range statistics, Uncached Refresh, live adjustment overlay, Cache Levels preference; the font menu opens on the current family, marked in the recent group when it is a recent one, #9160; Type options bar alignment and direction follow the target paragraph; a swatch click recolours selected type and shape layers with any tool, #9238; UI scale presets done: 105–120% steps, #3222; ⇧⌥ blend mode letters; painting tool Mode menus; ⌥ + an adjustment's shortcut reopens it at its last settings, ⌥⌘L / ⌥⌘M, #8900; Crop default mode: moving the image under the box snaps the frame's edges and centre, #8580; View › Extras hides the Move transform controls, #6699; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; Color panel modes from its panel menu, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; a picked colour recolours the selected type and shapes; Hand tool ⌘ / ⌥ are Zoom In / Zoom Out while held, #6434; the wheel steps value fields, #5473; a dragged guide shows its X or Y beside the pointer, #7680; Type options bar "T" icon scrubs the font size, #6437; Move tool: dragged selected pixels take their own outline as the selection, #7538; artboard backgrounds remain below child Free Transform previews; ⌫/Delete removes the selected smart filter, #4751; Object Finder foreground/background discrimination (#6548); rounded triangle, polygon and star corners; shape Fill/Stroke popovers accept hex RGB values, #6176; a guide let go over either ruler is removed, #6286; Crop rows corrected: saved crop presets and Delete Cropped Pixels off are done, #6562; marching ants in device pixels, #7489; Animated Zoom: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210; shape Density and Feather, TOOL-214-12, #5846; Pen Auto Add/Delete on the path being drawn, #6140; Show Transform Controls frames every selected layer; guide keys and clicks; menu bar from the keyboard, #4988; Crop tool Content-Aware Fill; on-canvas corner radius widgets, TOOL-214-12; Curvature Pen edits the active path; Clip Thumbnails to Layer Bounds; Pen ⇧ 45°; last selected tool restored at launch; Layers panel filter-type dropdown with Kind, Name and Mode, #5048; Free Transform box and marching ants follow the selection, #5297; History: the trash deletes the selected snapshot, rows drag onto the trash, #5324; smart filter reordering by drag; smart object perspective row corrected to done, #426; Free Transform H/V skew fields; toolbar tool shortcuts can be reassigned; ⇧-dragged guides land on ruler ticks; layer and selection keys; tool keys; spring-loaded tool letters; type formatting keys; Pen Auto Add/Delete, #4144; smart filter rows; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and the Add/Delete Anchor Point pair are live toolbar tools, Frame landed; no percentage changed; selection-modifier and ⌥-wheel rows match their tests; Properties › Transform shows a shape's path geometry, without its stroke) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 +> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-10 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-29 · **Change:** minor (stale rows corrected: tool flyouts open on press-and-hold or click-drag; Direct Selection arrow nudge of anchors and Smart Guides distances partial, #4486, #4946; Free Transform of several selected layers, #6501; Path Operations fixes: the first component keeps combining, a hidden component selection is left alone, a dragged live shape stays live, a refused Pen draft ends once; Pen, Freeform Pen, Curvature Pen and Path Selection Path Operations menu, which changes selected components, `+` / `-` keys, #1397; the Pen carries on an open shape or vector mask path; selection-aware font controls, pending caret fonts and focused commit, plus direct font-name editing with a compact no-match message, #9338; New Group dialog and button modifiers; new layers go into an open active group and join a clipping mask, except that type, shapes, pastes and placed files go above a group whose lock would refuse them; Color panel Hue and Brightness Cube show the out-of-gamut ⚠ and nearest printable colour when the field is at least 53 pt tall, #8672; 12 of 181 preferences do nothing, from the scorecard; Art History Brush in the History group of the Y flyout, partial, TOOL-213-20, #1610; Histogram panel: Compact / Expanded / All Channels views, Luminosity and Colors channels, Source, range statistics, Uncached Refresh, live adjustment overlay, Cache Levels preference; the font menu opens on the current family, marked in the recent group when it is a recent one, #9160; Type options bar alignment and direction follow the target paragraph; a swatch click recolours selected type and shape layers with any tool, #9238; UI scale presets done: 105–120% steps, #3222; ⇧⌥ blend mode letters; painting tool Mode menus; ⌥ + an adjustment's shortcut reopens it at its last settings, ⌥⌘L / ⌥⌘M, #8900; Crop default mode: moving the image under the box snaps the frame's edges and centre, #8580; View › Extras hides the Move transform controls, #6699; adjustment clipping stays visible in compact Properties, #5231; Color panel modes from its panel menu, the same in every theme, UI-217-17, #6000; a picked colour recolours the selected type and shapes; Hand tool ⌘ / ⌥ are Zoom In / Zoom Out while held, #6434; the wheel steps value fields, #5473; a dragged guide shows its X or Y beside the pointer, #7680; Type options bar "T" icon scrubs the font size, #6437; Move tool: dragged selected pixels take their own outline as the selection, #7538; artboard backgrounds remain below child Free Transform previews; ⌫/Delete removes the selected smart filter, #4751; Object Finder foreground/background discrimination (#6548); rounded triangle, polygon and star corners; shape Fill/Stroke popovers accept hex RGB values, #6176; a guide let go over either ruler is removed, #6286; Crop rows corrected: saved crop presets and Delete Cropped Pixels off are done, #6562; marching ants in device pixels, #7489; Animated Zoom: holding the Zoom tool zooms continuously, #6210; shape Density and Feather, TOOL-214-12, #5846; Pen Auto Add/Delete on the path being drawn, #6140; Show Transform Controls frames every selected layer; guide keys and clicks; menu bar from the keyboard, #4988; Crop tool Content-Aware Fill; on-canvas corner radius widgets, TOOL-214-12; Curvature Pen edits the active path; Clip Thumbnails to Layer Bounds; Pen ⇧ 45°; last selected tool restored at launch; Layers panel filter-type dropdown with Kind, Name and Mode, #5048; Free Transform box and marching ants follow the selection, #5297; History: the trash deletes the selected snapshot, rows drag onto the trash, #5324; smart filter reordering by drag; smart object perspective row corrected to done, #426; Free Transform H/V skew fields; toolbar tool shortcuts can be reassigned; ⇧-dragged guides land on ruler ticks; layer and selection keys; tool keys; spring-loaded tool letters; type formatting keys; Pen Auto Add/Delete, #4144; smart filter rows; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement, Red Eye and the Add/Delete Anchor Point pair are live toolbar tools, Frame landed; no percentage changed; selection-modifier and ⌥-wheel rows match their tests; Properties › Transform shows a shape's path geometry, without its stroke) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 How PhotoCraft's direct manipulation compares with Photoshop 2026 (27.11.0): the toolbox, the handles and modifier keys of each gesture, nudging, snapping, numeric precision, navigation, @@ -92,7 +92,7 @@ Triangle and Curvature Pen (minus legacy Rounded Rectangle and Targeted Adjustme | Arrow 1 px, ⇧-arrow 10 px for layers | done | `move_mods.rs` | | Arrow nudge of a selection outline (selection tools) | done | #1502 | | Arrow nudge of the crop box, X swaps orientation | done | TOOL-214-19 | -| Arrow nudge of path points with Direct Selection | done | `direct_select.rs` `arrow_keys`: the selected anchors move 1 px, ⇧ 10 px, one History step per press (`direct_select/tests.rs` `arrow_keys_nudge_the_selected_anchors`, #4486) | +| Arrow nudge of path points with Direct Selection | partial | `direct_select.rs` `arrow_keys`: the selected anchors move 1 px, ⇧ 10 px, one History step per press (`direct_select/tests.rs` `arrow_keys_nudge_the_selected_anchors`, #4486); a selected segment is not nudged, which Photoshop's arrow keys also move | | ⌘-arrow nudges the layer from any tool | missing | #2474 | | ⌥-drag duplicates, ⇧ constrains to 45° | done | `move_mods.rs` | | Dragging selected pixels shrinks the selection to them (the selection limited to where the layer has pixels, so moving again leaves no edge behind) as the drag starts, also with ⌥; the move box, snapping and Show Transform Controls use the moved pixels' bounds | done | #7538, `canvas.rs` `floating_outline` and `transform_controls_rect`, `snap_ui.rs` `follow_cut`, engine `float_cmds.rs` `CutParts::outline` | @@ -162,7 +162,7 @@ Triangle and Curvature Pen (minus legacy Rounded Rectangle and Targeted Adjustme | Snap to guides, grid, layers, document bounds and centre, selection, slices; Ctrl disables other gestures, while Distort corners snap to guides and intersections | done | `engine/src/snap.rs`, `snap_ui.rs` (actual-corner grab-offset regressions, #3632) | | Snap vector tools and transforms to the pixel grid | done | `snap_ui.rs:196` | | Smart guides (magenta alignment lines) | done | | -| Smart guide distance and spacing labels | partial | distances: with the Move tool, holding ⌘ over another layer or the canvas labels the distances in the ruler unit, and an ⌥-drag shows the distance to the copy (`move_distance.rs`, #4946); spacing labels not found | +| Smart guide distance and spacing labels | partial | distances: with the Move tool, holding ⌘ over another layer or the canvas labels the distances in the ruler unit, and an ⌥-drag shows the distance to the copy (`move_distance.rs`, #4946); no distances during an ordinary Move drag, and no spacing labels | | Ruler units px/in/cm/mm/pt/pica/% | done | | | ⇧-drag a guide out of a ruler: it lands on the nearest ruler tick | done | `rulers.rs` `snap_to_tick` (#3770) | | A dragged guide shows its position beside the pointer (X for vertical, Y for horizontal, in the ruler unit) | done | `rulers.rs` `guide_drag_readout` (#7680) | @@ -260,7 +260,7 @@ Paragraph; the rest open as in-app floating windows. | 2026-10-24 | minor | Path Selection selects path components and has the Path Operations menu; the menu and `+` / `-` change the selected components' operation (`path.setOperation`); the Pen carries on an open shape layer or vector mask path from its endpoint (#1397 feedback); row stays partial until the Shape tools have the menu; no percentage changed | | 2026-10-25 | minor | Every preference takes effect: 12 of 178 do nothing, the scorecard's count (it still said 46 of 149) | | 2026-10-25 | minor | Art History Brush is in the History group of the Y flyout (partial, TOOL-213-20, #1610) | -| 2026-10-24 | minor | Stale rows corrected against main: press-and-hold or click-drag opens a tool flyout (#2324, #2301) and Direct Selection arrows nudge the selected anchors (#4486) are done; Smart Guides distances with ⌘ held are partial (#4946); no percentage changed | +| 2026-10-24 | minor | Stale rows corrected against main: the tool flyout row is done for press-and-hold or click-drag (#2324, #2301); Direct Selection arrow nudge of selected anchors is partial (#4486; a selected segment is not nudged); Smart Guides distances with ⌘ held are partial (#4946); no percentage changed | | 2026-10-24 | minor | Color panel: Hue Cube and Brightness Cube show Photoshop's out-of-gamut ⚠ and the nearest printable colour under the chips when the field is at least 53 pt tall, as the slider modes did; a click takes it (#8672). No percentage changed | | 2026-10-24 | minor | Swatches: a click recolours the selected type layers and shape fills whatever the tool, as Photoshop 2025 does (measured with the Move and Brush tools); the Color panel still recolours them only with a Type, shape or Pen tool (#9238). Scores unchanged. | | 2026-10-24 | minor | Type options bar: the alignment and paragraph-direction buttons show the edited or selected type layer's paragraph instead of the tool defaults, as Photoshop's bar does. Scores unchanged. | From b19db160376f6f0f4e1a68f6c33964ee1827bc16 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: dotCooCoo Date: Fri, 30 Oct 2026 13:35:54 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 5/5] docs: drop stale flyout and path-point nudge claims from the parity assessment --- docs/target-app-parity.md | 7 ++++--- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/target-app-parity.md b/docs/target-app-parity.md index 25f54a8093..3be65b6b10 100644 --- a/docs/target-app-parity.md +++ b/docs/target-app-parity.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # PhotoCraft vs Adobe Photoshop: target-app parity -> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-12 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-27 · **Change:** minor (Smooth and Feather command masks cropped to selection bounds plus blur reach; cropped selection morphology and command mask conversion performance evidence added; 12 of 178 preferences do nothing, from the scorecard; the Camera Raw row names per-camera colour for non-DNG cameras as missing, not the Calibration panel, which landed 2026-10-13; Content-Aware Scale measurements added, #5236; Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch, DIST-220-1 partial, #5485; area type, TYPE-218-10 partial, Type scorecard 5 / 5 / 0; compound layer properties export as separate Photoshop Set events, #8304; JPEG Options dialog landed, FILE-215-19 partial; Print › Functions › Bleed through `file.print`; Content-Aware Move live preview for every selection size, TOOL-213-4 done, #6680; retouching evidence: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, only the Mixer Brush is left of TOOL-213-7; fill and adjustment layers copy and paste whole, UI-217-23 partial, #2344; shape layers take Density and Feather, TOOL-214-12 done, #5846; on-canvas corner radius widgets, TOOL-214-12; `.atn` import maps 112 events; Free Transform H/V skew fields; stale rows corrected against `main` and the scorecard, estimates unchanged; Photoshop Actions `.atn` load and save; 2026-10-10: Tilt-Shift measurements added; earlier the same day: major, full re-measure against Photoshop 2026 27.11.0; merged `parity-estimate.md` and the roadmap's honest assessment; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement and Red Eye are live toolbar tools, Frame landed; percentages unchanged; PSD spot plates in Photoshop's polarity, #7415 split; TIFF spot plates, FILE-215-17's TIFF part, #7415) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 +> **Last reviewed:** 2026-10-12 · **Last updated:** 2026-10-27 · **Change:** minor (stale entries corrected: tool flyouts open on press-and-hold or click-drag, #2324, and Direct Selection arrows nudge anchor points, #4486; Smooth and Feather command masks cropped to selection bounds plus blur reach; cropped selection morphology and command mask conversion performance evidence added; 12 of 178 preferences do nothing, from the scorecard; the Camera Raw row names per-camera colour for non-DNG cameras as missing, not the Calibration panel, which landed 2026-10-13; Content-Aware Scale measurements added, #5236; Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch, DIST-220-1 partial, #5485; area type, TYPE-218-10 partial, Type scorecard 5 / 5 / 0; compound layer properties export as separate Photoshop Set events, #8304; JPEG Options dialog landed, FILE-215-19 partial; Print › Functions › Bleed through `file.print`; Content-Aware Move live preview for every selection size, TOOL-213-4 done, #6680; retouching evidence: Pattern Stamp and Background Eraser draw live, only the Mixer Brush is left of TOOL-213-7; fill and adjustment layers copy and paste whole, UI-217-23 partial, #2344; shape layers take Density and Feather, TOOL-214-12 done, #5846; on-canvas corner radius widgets, TOOL-214-12; `.atn` import maps 112 events; Free Transform H/V skew fields; stale rows corrected against `main` and the scorecard, estimates unchanged; Photoshop Actions `.atn` load and save; 2026-10-10: Tilt-Shift measurements added; earlier the same day: major, full re-measure against Photoshop 2026 27.11.0; merged `parity-estimate.md` and the roadmap's honest assessment; stale missing-tool rows corrected: Color Replacement and Red Eye are live toolbar tools, Frame landed; percentages unchanged; PSD spot plates in Photoshop's polarity, #7415 split; TIFF spot plates, FILE-215-17's TIFF part, #7415) · **Target:** Adobe Photoshop 2026 The authoritative answer to "how close is PhotoCraft to Photoshop, and how much work is left". The one-page summary is [`ROADMAP.md`](../ROADMAP.md); the ranked work list is [`gaps.md`](gaps.md); @@ -156,7 +156,7 @@ workflows, PSD exchange edge cases, and everything excluded above. Discounts: launch and stability ×0.90 (start failures without a usable GPU, #2519, #2412, #1859; Type tool freeze, #2518); discoverability and UI clarity ×0.92 (language option not -found, #2532; flyouts only on right-click, #2301; toolbar hover issue, #2603); opening files +found, #2532; toolbar hover issue, #2603); opening files people send ×0.95 (JPEG, PNG, HEIC, WebP, PSD open; AVIF and PDF don't, #463, #2541). **78% × 0.90 × 0.92 × 0.95 ≈ 61%** (range 55–67), estimated. @@ -174,7 +174,7 @@ parity for the area and are already contained in the dimension rows above. | Transform, warp, puppet, perspective, liquify | 55% | 100–180 | Free Transform modifiers right, with a right-click transform menu (TOOL-214-5) and H/V skew fields; Puppet Warp mesh follows the object outline (TOOL-214-6); Liquify called "useless" by a user (#2606) | | Adjustments and filters | 70% | 120–200 | All present; smart-filter re-render matches Photoshop on 5 of 30 files; Filter Gallery looks approximate; no Neural Filters | | Type | 40% | 120–200 | Engine works; manual/optical kerning, a live Warp Text preview and variable-font axis sliders (2026-10-11); type on a path only places glyphs rigidly (TYPE-218-1 partial); no RTL paragraphs, OpenType panel UI; Type tool freeze on macOS (#2518) | -| Vector shapes and paths | 55% | 80–140 | Pen, Direct/Path Selection, shapes, shape strokes. Freeform and Curvature Pen (#1054). Add/Delete Anchor Point and Convert Point tools exist (`Tool` enum); on-canvas corner radius widgets on live rectangles (TOOL-214-12, 2026-10-13); shape Density and Feather, the path as the fill's soft vector mask, matching Photoshop's 10 px feather ramp within 1 level (#5846, 2026-10-15); missing path-point nudge; shape parity tracking issue #2496 | +| Vector shapes and paths | 55% | 80–140 | Pen, Direct/Path Selection, shapes, shape strokes. Freeform and Curvature Pen (#1054). Add/Delete Anchor Point and Convert Point tools exist (`Tool` enum); on-canvas corner radius widgets on live rectangles (TOOL-214-12, 2026-10-13); shape Density and Feather, the path as the fill's soft vector mask, matching Photoshop's 10 px feather ramp within 1 level (#5846, 2026-10-15); Direct Selection arrows nudge the selected anchors (#4486) but not a selected segment; shape parity tracking issue #2496 | | Colour management and modes | 70% | 60–100 | Own ICC engine, soft proof, CMYK/Lab/Indexed/Duotone/Multichannel; no Adobe CMYK profiles, spot plates in PSD and TIFF only (FILE-215-17: no RGB/CMYK spot preview or PDF Separation), monitor profile only at launch | | Camera Raw and computational photo (Photomerge, HDR, lens) | 45% | 120–200 | Raw for DNG/CR2/NEF/ARW/RW2/ORF/RAF(uncompressed)/PEF; no CR3; ACR dialog partial (no masking; no per-camera colour for non-DNG cameras); generic lens profiles only | | Automation, actions, batch, scripting | 45% | 120–200 | CLI/MCP/control channel ahead of Photoshop; Actions panel and recording not document-independent (AUTO-219-1/2); `.atn` load/save since 2026-10-12 (112 events mapped, the rest kept verbatim); compound layer properties export as separate Set events with rename last (#8304, 2026-10-21; independent Photoshop replay pending); no ExtendScript/UXP | @@ -590,6 +590,7 @@ See [method, raw measurements and reproduction](five-algorithm-performance.md). | 2026-10-26 | minor | Expand/Contract/Border distance work, mask reads and replacement cropped to nonzero bounds; bounded distances for radii ≤5; 36 MP exact-output comparisons improve 1.54–37.82× across eight cases; percentages, estimates and scorecard budgets unchanged | | 2026-10-23 | minor | Select and Mask is Photoshop's workspace with its own tools (#7069, #8148); TOOL-214-1 stays partial (Refine Hair, Object Aware, Presets); percentages and estimates unchanged | | 2026-10-25 | minor | UI / UX and Workspace rows: 12 of 178 preferences do nothing, the scorecard's count. Camera Raw row: the Calibration panel landed on 2026-10-13 (#5128); what is missing is per-camera colour for non-DNG cameras ([gaps.md](gaps.md) G14). Percentages and estimates unchanged | +| 2026-10-24 | minor | Discoverability discount: removed the stale "flyouts only on right-click" reason, since a press held or dragged off a toolbar button opens its flyout (#2324); Vector shapes and paths: Direct Selection arrows nudge the selected anchors (#4486), not yet a selected segment; the ×0.92 discount and the percentages are unchanged | | 2026-10-23 | minor | Colour management and modes: PSD spot plates are stored as Photoshop stores them (ink 0 = solid), and PSDs from earlier PhotoCraft versions keep their ink (#7415 split, part 4); estimates unchanged | | 2026-10-23 | minor | Colour management and modes: spot plates now save and open in TIFF (#7415); estimates unchanged | | 2026-10-22 | minor | Platforms: Help › Check for Updates and an opt-out check once per launch (#5485), DIST-220-1 partial; percentages unchanged |