The Limits entry from 79f5839 said what goes wrong but not why it is left.
It now says that such a file is outside the MP4 specification: an MP4 AAC
sample is one raw access unit with the configuration in the sample
description (ISO/IEC 14496-14, 14496-3), so ADTS headers do not belong in
it, and a sample's duration is the time it decodes to (ISO/IEC 14496-12).
It says why files within the specification are not affected, what still
works, and why seeks and edits in such files are not corrected: finding
where each sample's audio starts means counting the ADTS frames in every
sample before it, one read per sample, which would slow every ADTS-framed
MP4 at open to work around files outside the specification.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
craft-audio
Audio file I/O and codecs for the Craft apps. Native implementations: WAV and AIFF read/write, FLAC encoder, AAC decoder. Formats without a native decoder are decoded by symphonia, which is to be replaced by native decoders.
- Input is a byte slice or any
ByteSource(a file, a shared buffer); output is byte vectors or anyWrite + Seek. The crate opens no files itself. - Decoded audio is planar
f32, full scale ±1, inAudioBuffer(sample_rate, oneVec<f32>per channel), in WAV channel order (L R C LFE, back, side) whenever the channel layout is known. - Malformed input returns an error, never a panic (see symphonia for the one
exception). No
unsafe. Readers and decoders are tested with corrupted and truncated input. - Implemented from the published specifications; tested against ffmpeg.
Builds for
wasm32-unknown-unknown. - Containers (MP4/MOV, Matroska/WebM, Ogg), bit I/O and the
Container/CodecId/CodecParamstypes come fromcraft-media. This crate never depends on video codecs.
Cargo features
No default features. The shared types (AudioBuffer, AudioInfo, ChannelLayout, AudioError,
EncodeOptions, ByteSource, …) build with none.
| Feature | Provides | Pulls in |
|---|---|---|
decode |
decode, probe, Decoder, tracks, TrackDecoder; every format in Format support |
decode-native, symphonia |
decode-native |
the same, native formats only (others are Unsupported) |
aac-decode, craft-media isobmff/matroska/ogg, log |
symphonia |
the fallback for formats with no native decoder; turning it on is the same as decode |
decode-native, symphonia |
encode |
every encoder: the WAV, AIFF and FLAC file writers | lossless-encode |
lossless-encode |
WAV, AIFF and FLAC writing | pcm-encode, flac-encode |
pcm-encode |
encode, FileEncoder for WAV and AIFF; wav_float_header |
none |
flac-encode |
encode, FileEncoder for FLAC |
craft-media bitstream |
aac-decode |
aac::Decoder |
craft-media bitstream |
peaks |
peaks::Peaks |
none |
serde |
Serialize/Deserialize on the shared types |
serde |
aac-decode also gives TrackDecoder, for AAC and PCM.
An app that decodes 32-bit FLAC with decode needs a profile override in its workspace; see
symphonia.
WAV, AIFF and FLAC export only (no decoders, no demuxers, no symphonia):
craft-audio = { git = "https://github.com/storytold/craft-libs", rev = "<commit>", features = ["lossless-encode"] }
Decode, every encoder and waveform overviews:
craft-audio = { git = "https://github.com/storytold/craft-libs", rev = "<commit>", features = ["decode", "encode", "peaks"] }
Packets from an app's own demuxer, AAC:
craft-audio = { git = "https://github.com/storytold/craft-libs", rev = "<commit>", features = ["aac-decode"] }
craft-audio re-exports the craft-media types its API uses (ByteSource, ReadSeekSource,
CodecParams, …), and craft-media itself as craft_audio::craft_media. Use that to reach the
containers directly (for example to pass an isobmff::Track's codec_params() to
TrackDecoder); decode-native turns on all three. A separate craft-media dependency must use
the same rev as craft-audio: with two revisions Cargo builds two copies, and their types do
not match.
Usage
Runnable versions are in examples/:
cargo run -p craft-audio --example info --features decode -- take.m4a
cargo run -p craft-audio --example encode --features lossless-encode -- out
cargo run -p craft-audio --example stream --features decode -- long-recording.m4a 60
cargo run -p craft-audio --example packets --features decode -- take.m4a
stream takes a file and a start time in seconds; packets takes an MP4 file. The entry points
(decode, probe, tracks, Decoder, TrackDecoder, encode, FileEncoder) and the
functions around them have rustdoc examples.
Decode a file
use craft_audio::{decode, probe};
let bytes = std::fs::read("take.m4a")?;
// Container, codec, rate, speaker layout and length. Read from the headers; when they give no
// length (an MP3 without a Xing frame, PCM in Matroska), the file is decoded to count it.
let info = probe(&bytes, Some("m4a"))?;
println!("{} in {}, {} Hz, {}", info.codec.name(), info.container.name(), info.sample_rate, info.layout);
// The first audio track: planar f32 in WAV channel order, trimmed to its presentation length.
let (info, buf) = decode(&bytes, Some("m4a"))?;
let left: &[f32] = &buf.channels[0];
decode returns TooLarge above 2³⁰ samples (4 GiB of f32). info.damaged counts packets
that were damaged and replaced by silence of their length.
Choose a track
use craft_audio::{DecodeOptions, decode_with, tracks};
let list = tracks(&bytes, None)?; // codec, rate and channels of every audio track
if let Some(second) = list.get(1) {
let opts = DecodeOptions::default().with_track(second.index);
let (info, buf) = decode_with(&bytes, None, &opts)?;
}
A track index the file does not have is Unsupported. DecodeOptions::with_max_samples sets
another size limit. tracks_of lists the tracks of a file read from a ByteSource;
detect_container names a file's container from its first bytes.
Stream and seek
use craft_audio::{DecodeOptions, Decoder};
let file = std::fs::File::open("long-recording.m4a")?;
let mut dec = Decoder::open(file, Some("m4a"), &DecodeOptions::default())?;
dec.seek(48_000 * 60)?; // sample-exact (see Limits): the next block starts here
while let Some(block) = dec.next_block()? {
// block.channels: planar f32, WAV channel order
}
Decoder::open takes any ByteSource that is Send + Sync (SharedSource): a Vec<u8> or
Arc<[u8]>, a ReadSeekSource around any Read + Seek, or a std::fs::File. Prefer
ReadSeekSource for files: it takes the length once and reports a failure when it is made. On
single-threaded WebAssembly the source need not be Send, so a reader over a JS Blob works.
Decoder::from_bytes does the same for a borrowed buffer.
seek returns the frame decoding resumes at. A seek to or past the end of a file whose length is
known stops at the end, and the next next_block returns None. When length_known() is false,
info().frames is 0: add up the block lengths, or call Decoder::probe, which decodes the rest
of the file to count them. Decoder::probe is also how to probe a file on disk.
Native formats read their samples from the source packet by packet. The container's packet index stays in memory (tens of bytes per packet), and opening a Matroska file or a raw ADTS stream reads through the whole file to build it. Formats symphonia decodes are read whole first.
A damaged packet is concealed and counted in info().damaged. A source that fails a read (a
network drop) returns AudioError::Io from next_block instead, and that packet is skipped. To
retry it, keep the position: start from the frame the last seek returned (0 without one), add
each block's frames, and seek to that position.
Decode packets from your own demuxer
TrackDecoder takes a track's CodecParams and the first packets. The parameters come from any
craft-media demuxer's codec_params() (see
craft-media's codec parameters), or
are built with CodecParams::new for another container:
use craft_audio::{CodecId, CodecParams, TrackDecoder};
let params = CodecParams::new(CodecId::Aac).with_extradata(asc).with_sample_rate(48_000);
let lookahead: Vec<&[u8]> = packets.iter().take(craft_audio::LOOKAHEAD_PACKETS).map(Vec::as_slice).collect();
let mut dec = TrackDecoder::new(¶ms, &lookahead)?;
for p in &packets {
let block = dec.decode(p).or_else(|_| dec.conceal(Some(p)))?;
}
It decodes AAC (finding HE-AAC in the lookahead) and PCM, and returns AudioBuffers in WAV
order when layout() is ordered. codec(), sample_rate() and layout() describe the output. Container timing is the caller's.
Streams without codec configuration work where the packets carry it. AAC with empty extradata
takes its configuration from the ADTS headers (MPEG-TS, raw .aac), which are stripped from each
packet.
To seek: position your demuxer at the packet that starts preroll() frames or more before the
target, call reset(), decode from there, and drop the output before the target.
The codec modules are also usable on their own. aac::Decoder returns the codec's channel order;
aac::wav_order(channel_config) maps it to WAV order.
Encode a file
use craft_audio::{AudioBuffer, BitDepth, ChannelLayout, EncodeFormat, EncodeOptions, FileEncoder, encode};
// One Vec of samples per channel, full scale ±1. `AudioBuffer::new(rate, channels, frames)`
// makes a silent one to fill.
let buf = AudioBuffer { sample_rate: 48_000, channels: vec![left, right] };
let opts = EncodeOptions::new(EncodeFormat::Flac).with_bit_depth(BitDepth::Int24).with_dither(true);
let flac: Vec<u8> = encode(&buf, &opts)?;
// 5.1 with side surrounds: a layout other than the default for 6 channels, recorded in the WAV.
let wav = encode(&surround, &EncodeOptions::default().with_layout(ChannelLayout::SURROUND_5_1_SIDE))?;
// Block by block into any Write + Seek with nothing after its position; the same bytes as `encode`.
let mut enc = FileEncoder::new(std::fs::File::create("take.wav")?, &EncodeOptions::default(), 48_000, 2)?;
enc.write(&buf.channels, buf.frames())?; // one slice (or Vec) per channel
enc.finish()?;
EncodeOptions::default() is 24-bit WAV. with_bwf adds a BWF bext chunk and
with_force_rf64 writes RF64 below 4 GiB; both apply to WAV only. encode_format_for("aiff")
maps an extension to an EncodeFormat, and ENCODE_EXTENSIONS lists the extensions the enabled
features can write. write refuses a block without one slice per channel, or with a slice
shorter than frames, and writes nothing. After a write fails for another reason, every later
write and finish returns an error.
Waveform overviews
use craft_audio::peaks::Peaks;
let peaks = Peaks::build(&left); // once per channel
// Start sample, samples per column, overlap, columns; pass the same samples each time. One
// (min, max) per column, `None` past the end of the data.
let columns = peaks.spans(&left, 0.0, 512.0, 0.0, 800);
Peaks is a min/max/sum-of-squares pyramid (32-sample blocks, fan-out 4). Range queries are
exact, O(log n). rms_spans returns one RMS value per column.
Errors
Functions return craft_audio::Result<T>. The codec modules have their own Error types, which
convert into AudioError with ?.
AudioError |
Cause |
|---|---|
Unsupported |
valid input using an unsupported codec, feature or option, or a format whose feature is off |
Malformed |
corrupt or truncated input, or not the claimed format |
TooLarge |
over a size limit (DecodeOptions::max_samples, an allocation) |
Encode |
an encoder rejected the input or its settings (a buffer with no channels or a 0 Hz rate, a block shorter than its frame count, a wrong layout) |
Io |
the source failed a read, or the FileEncoder writer failed |
AudioError is #[non_exhaustive], so a match needs a _ arm:
match craft_audio::decode(&bytes, None) {
Ok((info, buf)) => { /* … */ }
Err(craft_audio::AudioError::Unsupported(what)) => eprintln!("cannot decode: {what}"),
Err(e) => eprintln!("{e}"),
}
Format support
| Format | Decode | Encode |
|---|---|---|
| WAV, BWF, RF64/BW64 | native | native |
| AIFF, AIFF-C | native | native |
| FLAC | symphonia | native |
| AAC-LC | native | — |
| HE-AAC v1/v2 | native, core only (see Limits) | — |
| MP1, MP2, MP3 (MPEG audio Layer I/II/III) | symphonia | — |
| ALAC, Vorbis, ADPCM, A-law, µ-law | symphonia | — |
| Opus | — | — |
| Container | Demuxer | Timing |
|---|---|---|
| MP4, M4A, MOV | craft_media::isobmff for native codecs; symphonia for the others (ALAC, MP3, FLAC) |
edit lists (AAC priming) |
| Matroska, WebM | craft_media::matroska for native codecs; symphonia for the others (Vorbis, FLAC, MP3) |
CodecDelay, DiscardPadding |
| Ogg | symphonia (Vorbis, FLAC) | — |
| Raw ADTS AAC | native frame sync | — |
| Raw MP1/MP2/MP3 | symphonia | — |
| FLAC | symphonia | — |
| CAF | symphonia | — |
Limits
-
HE-AAC: the AAC-LC core is decoded.
decode,DecoderandTrackDecoderupsample it 2×;aac::Decoderalone outputs the core rate. SBR is not reconstructed, so there is no content above the core's Nyquist frequency. -
HE-AAC v2: parametric stereo is not reconstructed either, so the mono core decodes as mono.
-
AAC: Main, SSR and LTP profiles, coupling channels and 960-sample frames are unsupported.
-
Raw ADTS: frames with several raw data blocks are unsupported: a stream of them is refused, and one among other frames decodes as silence of its length and counts as damaged, as does a frame that changes the stream's sample rate, profile or channel configuration.
-
A seek into AAC with PNS gives the same samples each time, but its noise differs from a continuous decode's, at the same band energy.
-
MP4 gapless information outside an edit list is not read: a file from Apple's encoders with
iTunSMPBand noelstdecodes with its priming and padding. -
AAC channel configuration 7 and program-config layouts, and AIFF with more than four channels, decode with an unordered layout, in the codec's order.
-
A Matroska track with no block durations (AAC from ffmpeg 6) ends at its
DURATIONtag, when that ends inside the last packet. Otherwise all its audio is presented, including any padding. -
ffmpeg before 9 ends some codecs' tracks in MP4 and Matroska up to 11 ms early. The audio past the end a file declares is not presented.
-
A Matroska track's end comes from its timestamps, so it is known to one timestamp tick (usually 1 ms) unless the last block has
DiscardPadding. -
A FLAC layout that decoders would not assume for the channel count depends on its
WAVEFORMATEXTENSIBLE_CHANNEL_MASKcomment. This includes the usual layouts for 5 and 6 channels: without the comment, back surrounds are read as side surrounds. It includes the usual 7-channel layout too: without the comment, its back left, back right and back centre are read as back centre, side left and side right. -
FLAC at 32 bits codes stereo channels independently, because a side channel would need 33 bits.
-
Outside RFC 9639's streamable subset (§7), which some decoders require: FLAC at 32 bits, at a sample rate the frame header cannot name, or with a layout that needs the mask comment.
-
ChannelLayout::unorderedis written to FLAC as mask0x0000, as RFC 9639 §8.6.2 allows, but ffmpeg andflac -dignore that mask and use their default layout for the channel count. -
Not decoded at all: AC-3, E-AC-3, Opus and Speex.
-
TrackDecoderreturnsUnsupportedfor MP3, FLAC, ALAC and Vorbis;decodeandDecoderread those through symphonia. -
MP4 edit lists: a single media edit (encoder priming and the end) is applied, alone or after one empty edit; the empty edit's delay is not added as silence. Other edit lists are not applied, and the media plays as it is stored.
-
AAC in MP4 stored as ADTS frames, when the sample durations count fewer frames than the samples hold: HE-AAC durations that count only the core frames, or several frames in a sample timed as one. Such a file is broken: it is outside the MP4 specification in two ways.
- An MP4 AAC sample is one raw access unit, with the stream's configuration in the sample
description (ISO/IEC 14496-14 and 14496-3). ADTS is a transport framing for streams such as
MPEG-TS and raw
.aac, and its headers do not belong in an MP4 sample. - A sample's duration in the time-to-sample table is the time it decodes to (ISO/IEC 14496-12). Durations that count fewer frames than the samples hold do not describe the track.
ffmpeg, Apple's encoders, phones and cameras write raw AAC with matching durations, and a correct remux from MPEG-TS or raw
.aacconverts the framing, so files within the specification are not affected. In a file outside it:- Read from the start, the track decodes in full: durations that fall short of the frames in the samples read at open do not end it.
Decoder::seekplaces samples by those durations, so it lands later than asked, and an edit list measured in them can end the track early.- These are not corrected because where each sample's audio starts is only known by counting the ADTS frames in every sample before it: one read per sample, hundreds of thousands on a two-hour track. Done at open, that would slow every ADTS-framed MP4 to work around files that are outside the specification.
- An MP4 AAC sample is one raw access unit, with the stream's configuration in the sample
description (ISO/IEC 14496-14 and 14496-3). ADTS is a transport framing for streams such as
MPEG-TS and raw
Codecs
Each codec module's rustdoc lists the coding tools it implements.
| Codec | Spec | Scope | Verified against |
|---|---|---|---|
| WAV, AIFF | Microsoft RIFF, Apple AIFF/AIFF-C | read: integer 8–32-bit, float 32/64-bit, WAVE_FORMAT_EXTENSIBLE masks, RF64/BW64, BWF bext, truncated files; write: 16/24/32-bit integer and 32-bit float, RF64 above 4 GiB, any layout, TPDF dither |
round trips; hostile-input tests |
| FLAC encoder | RFC 9639 | 16, 24, 32 bits; 1–8 channels, layouts decoders would not assume for the count as a WAVEFORMATEXTENSIBLE_CHANNEL_MASK comment; up to 655,350 Hz; LPC, stereo decorrelation, wasted bits, STREAMINFO MD5 |
bit-exact through ffmpeg, STREAMINFO MD5 checked against ffmpeg |
AAC (aac) |
ISO/IEC 14496-3 | AAC-LC decode, 1–8 channels; HE-AAC: see Limits | ffmpeg: ~135 dB SNR; PNS noise differs per sample at equal band energy |
symphonia
symphonia 0.6 (MPL-2.0, used unmodified as the Craft licensing rules require) decodes the formats
marked "symphonia" in Format support. Each is to be replaced by a native
decoder, after which the dependency is removed. The native path is tried first, so a new native
decoder takes its formats over without an API change. Build with decode-native instead of
decode to see what still needs symphonia.
Notes while symphonia is in use:
-
symphonia reads from memory: a file it decodes is read whole first. Its decoded audio still streams through
Decoder. -
symphonia allocates sizes taken from the file. Container size fields of WAV, FLAC, MP4 and CAF files are checked against the file length before symphonia reads them.
-
AAC in CAF: the priming is not trimmed and
Decoder::seekis not sample-exact, as CAF goes through symphonia. -
A panic inside symphonia is caught and returned as
AudioError::Malformedonly where panics unwind: native builds with the defaultpanic = "unwind". Onwasm32-unknown-unknown, and in an app built withpanic = "abort", such a panic aborts. The native decoders do not panic. -
symphonia-bundle-flacoverflows ani32add on 32-bit LPC FLAC; the wrapped value is correct. Release builds decode correctly; debug builds panic (returned asMalformed). Apps that decode 32-bit FLAC need this in the workspaceCargo.toml(craft-libs has it):[profile.dev.package.symphonia-bundle-flac] overflow-checks = false
Tests
Both integration test binaries need features, so a plain cargo test -p craft-audio runs only
the unit tests. Run everything with:
cargo test -p craft-audio --all-features
Tests that need ffmpeg are skipped when it is missing. To fail instead, set
CRAFT_MEDIA_REQUIRE_ORACLES=1. The helpers and their variables are shared with craft-media (see
its tests). The test files describe what they check;
tests/codecs/routing_oracle.rs is the end-to-end check of containers, codecs, timing, seeking
and track choice against ffmpeg.
CI (.github/workflows/audio.yml) runs clippy for each feature on its own, rustdoc with warnings
as errors, the WASM build, encode-only and native-only test runs, and an MSRV check. It also runs
the full tests with ffmpeg required.
Origin
| Part | Source |
|---|---|
WAV, AIFF, decode/probe, peaks |
SoundCraft soundcraft-audio-io 7dc56a4 |
| FLAC encoder, AAC | FilmCraft 8fda2f2 |
Where apps had overlapping implementations, the one that measured better was kept, with the tests of both:
| Format | Kept | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| FLAC encoding | FilmCraft | 0.1–37% smaller output than SoundCraft's on 12 test signals; STREAMINFO MD5 |
| WAV/AIFF writing | SoundCraft | only one with BWF, dither, arbitrary speaker masks, streaming without known length |
| AAC-LC decoding | FilmCraft (over symphonia) | equal SNR against ffmpeg; also decodes 5.1 AAC, which symphonia rejects |
Migration notes for apps
For the apps switching from their own code; to be removed once all three have switched.
The codec modules' public items keep their names, so apps can re-export them
(pub use craft_audio::aac::*;). Names kept only for that are #[doc(hidden)]:
aac::Upsample2x, aac::ProgramConfig::parse, aac::config_layout and aac::sample_rate_index.
What else an app adjusts:
AudioInfohascontainer,codec,layoutanddamagedinstead of SoundCraft'sformat.detect_containerreplacesdetect_format.probereports the layout instead ofwav_channel_mask.EncodeOptionsis built withEncodeOptions::new(format)andwith_*methods. It carries the speaker layout and RF64, which replaceencode_with_layout,encode_wav_rf64andFileEncoder::new's layout argument.BwfInfois built the same way.ENCODE_EXTENSIONSis a list.- Arguments go sample rate, then channels, and channel counts are
u16:FileEncoder::new(out, &opts, sample_rate, channels),wav_float_header(sample_rate, channels, frames),AudioBuffer::new(sample_rate, channels, frames),AudioBuffer::from_interleavedandnum_channels, and theChannelLayoutconstructors andchannels(). AudioInfo,AudioError,EncodeOptions,BwfInfo,SampleFormat,BitDepth, the codecErrorenums and the codec modules' header, frame and config structs (but foraac::ProgramConfig) are#[non_exhaustive].Speaker::ALLis a slice.TrackInfo::sample_rateandchannelsareOptions.- Features are per codec. SoundCraft's
encode(WAV, AIFF, FLAC) is nowlossless-encode, made ofpcm-encode(WAV, AIFF) andflac-encode.encodeturns on every encoder. Writing a format whose feature is off returnsAudioError::Unsupported. FileEncoder::writetakes any per-channel slices, but refuses a block with missing channels or short slices instead of filling them with silence.DecodeOptionsis notCopy.- The FLAC encoder's vendor string is
craft-audio <version>. decodetries native decoders first. AAC no longer goes through symphonia, except in CAF. MP4 and Matroska files decode to presentation length. A packet that fails is concealed, not dropped. A failed source read isAudioError::Io.